Is there still room on the road for manual transmissions?

According to Wikipedia, the first automatic transmission, "the … Sturtevant ‘horseless carriage gearbox,’” was designed in 1904. But it wasn't until 1939 that General Motors introduced its Hydramatic transmission. And it was a few years after that before automatic transmissions were widely available in vehicles purchased by the general public.

Since that time, the automatics have taken over American roads.

According to the April 7, 2016, issue of ‘The Zebra’ for comparing insurance quotes, only “3.9 percent of cars sold in (the) U.S. were built with manual transmissions.” But, back in 1986, of “vehicles on American roads" 29 percent had manual transmissions.

The popularity of the automatic transmission, however, never really caught on overseas. As of the time that ‘The Zebra’ article was written (2016), 80 percent of the cars sold in Europe and Japan still had manual transmissions. Do they know something we don’t? Probably not.

For years, manual transmissions were considered better on fuel economy. Advancements in automatic transmissions have narrowed the gap. Still, Consumer Reports rates manual transmissions as providing 2 to 5 mpg better mileage than automatics. That's a significant check in the manual transmission column. But is it decisive?

For those who want superior performance in a vehicle, manual transmissions were long considered the king of the road. But improvements in automatic transmissions have closed that gap. Among drag racers, automatics are generally considered superior to manual transmissions when it comes to shaving time off the elapsed time in a quarter or eighth mile. That check mark probably fits in the automatic column.

One area where the manual has consistently held the title is in terms of price. When purchasing a vehicle, Consumer Reports indicates that you can save $8,000 to $12,000 if you opt for a manual transmission over a manual. Our research has not seen that large of a variance, however. For instance, we checked on the difference in cost for a 2020 Mustang and found that the 10-speed SelectShift Automatic Transmission only cost $1,595 more than the standard equipment 6-Speed Manual Transmission. Still, that is a significant savings.

So what's the final verdict? Is there still room on American roads. What it probably comes down to is that some people simply prefer a manual transmission, people who look forward to driving as something more than just getting from here to there. Many don't want to be bothered with coordinating the shifter and clutch. They want to get in and go from Point A to Point B with as little work as possible. It's possible that the prior group may have the same response to automatic/driverless cars. They enjoy the drive and aren't looking for the car to take over.

Comments

Is your antifreeze safe from freezing this Richmond winter

You still have time to have it checked Well, there’s no denying it – winter tends to get chilly here in Richmond. We have to deal with snow and ice on the roads, scraping the same off our windows and windshield, and staying warm while we drive. Of course, you had your antifreeze checked before winter rolled into town. What?! You didn’t have your antifreeze checked before winter clamped down on Richmond? So, how’s your antifreeze doing? If you haven’t had it checked, there’s really no way of knowing, is there? This car has overheated in the middle of a Richmond winter. But, on the other end of the spectrum, the antifreeze can also freeze if it's not up to its job. Hopefully, you haven’t had a serious problem with your antifreeze already. If you did, you’d probably know. When antifreeze fails, it’s a potentially catastrophic condition for your vehicle’s engine. You could have hoses that have burst because of freezing antifreeze. Worse than that, your engine block may have crac...

Blocks of ice falling from cars in McHenry could cause accidents or damage

We’ve all seen those blocks of snow falling from behind the rear tires of a car when the snow rolls into McHenry . Fortunately, they’re just packed snow that will disintegrate under your vehicle’s tires as you simply drive right through them, right? Don’t count on it. Those blocks of snow are often packed so tight, condensed by the thaw-and-freeze cycle, that they’re anything but oversized snowballs . They’re often more like boulders. Hit one of those blocks and the collision between the block and one of your tires could send you careening off the road or into oncoming traffic. In some cases, they’re so solid you could pound them with a sledgehammer with little effect. They truly can represent a serious road hazard. The problem is that it’s difficult to tell how solidly they’re packed when you see them on the road, left their unwittingly by another driver. Either way, your best bet is to try to avoid them. But you want to be careful dodging blocks of ice in the road, too. You need...

Get out to McHenry Music Festival for a good time and music near to home

Some folks here in McHenry will load up the car and head out to Red Rock Amphitheater near Denver to see a show. Some will go to the MSG Sphere near Las Vegas. Some will go to the Bonaroo Festival Concert to see a show. That’s quite a bit of driving and you’d better make sure your vehicle is up to the trip. What happens, however, if something goes wrong – if your vehicle breaks down while driving there or back? What happens if the show is canceled, as happened this year with the Bonaroo Festival? We’re talking about some serious inconvenience, aren’t we? Wherever you go, whether your driving to Colorado, Nevada, Tennessee or anywhere else in this continent, you want to perform your due diligence and make sure the vehicle is up for the trip before you go. And it doesn’t really matter if you’re driving somewhere to see some live music or for any other purpose. A breakdown can be costly and may put you at the mercy of weather conditions or nefarious characters that come across you while y...

Performance Unlimited Blog

Search This Blog